Book Reviews / Books / Books 2015 / Manga / Top Banana Books

Manga Review: “A Silent Voice, Volume 1” by Yoshitoki Ōima

 A Silent Voice, Volume 1 By  Yoshitoki Ōima Review by Celadon

A Silent Voice, Volume 1
By Yoshitoki Ōima
Review by Celadon

I love graphic novels and manga. I worked at a comic book store for three years, two of them as a manager. Graphic novels/manga are something I feel passionate about and that inspired my last resolution: to update the manga/GN collection at the Carrollton Public Library and to read/review them with more regularity.


Dated meme is dated, but I don’t care; Hyperbole and a Half is awesome. And it perfectly describes how I feel.

In light of that, new series have been ordered, and “A Silent Voice” (Koe no Katachi, literally “The Shape of Voice” ) by Yoshitoki Ōima, might be my new favorites.
The basic premise: This is a shonen manga that was originally written as a one-shot. It follows Shoya Ishida, a daredevil and a bully, as he meets a new transfer student, Shoko Nishimiya, a girl who is deaf.
She seems like a complete alien to him and she becomes Shoya’s favorite target, bullying her to the point where she transfers schools. Six years later, Shoya meets her again and tries to make up for past mistakes.
The plot: For volume one, they honestly give away the plot on the back of the book. It starts out with Shoya meeting Shoka in high school, and then jumping back six years to when they first met. The rest of volume one chronicles what Shoya was like at that age, how he treated Shoka, and how his classmates responded to both Shoya and Shoka.

Even though the scribbling on cats is pretty amusing, he still wins the “jerk of the year” award.

Scribbling on cats is pretty amusing, but he still wins the “jerk of the year” award.

Spoilers: Shoya is not a particularly good guy.

The art: Aesthetically, it’s quite beautiful. Ōima has a fairly modern style with clean lines and minimalistic shading. Scenes are dynamic and Ōima isn’t afraid of drawing his characters at any angles, which keeps the scenes dynamic and full of variety. The character design is much closer to what “real” people look like, forgoing crazy clothes, colors, and hairstyles that would be very normal in most other manga. For manga, they also have smaller eyes than a lot of typical shojo (i.e. eyes don’t take up half their face).

I mean, everyone’s hair still looks great, but there’s a lack of spikes and color that is normal in even slice of life manga.

Everyone’s hair still looks great even though there’s a lack of spikes and gravity-defying bangs. 

The verdict: Everyone loves an underdog. It’s one of the reasons Spiderman and Naruto are so popular. There’s something great about being able to cheer a character along and see their hopes and dreams realized. They’re easy to empathize with because everyone’s had bad days. Sometimes they’re really bad days. And it’s nice to read that bad days get better.

Naruto is pretty much the personification of the underdog winning awesomely eventually.

Naruto is pretty much the personification of the underdog winning awesomely eventually.

This is not that kind of book.

In a lot of ways, it’s a manga about how life isn’t fair. Near the beginning of the book, Shoya’s teacher tells him that “There are some things in this world that you just have to deal with.” Sometimes it’s a physical handicap, sometimes it’s something you caused, and sometimes that thing you are dealing with is horrifically unfair, but just because it’s unfair doesn’t make it go away.

This is a fairly different manga. It’s very slice-of-life, but without the typical over-the-top characters and antics. It’s also incredibly interesting to read a book where the main character is the kind of person that’s usually an antagonist, not a protagonist. Ōima does an incredible job of making him relatable while not condoning his bullying actions.

Warning: Reading this book might cause the reader to become uncomfortably self-aware of their own social decisions. Want to take that chance? You can find this manga here!
The verdict: I give this a 5 stars of 5 stars and declare it a Top Banana book. …don’t worry, most books will not get this verdict. We’re just starting the year on a super positive note.

An official top banana award. The greatest of awards.

An official top banana award. The greatest of awards.

Note: Want to find out more about the manga/graphic novels we have? Subscribe to our teen graphic novels newsletter here!

Information about the manga taken from:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s